Play It Again Sports has become a go-to spot for folks looking to buy or sell used sports gear. Whether you're a parent trying to outfit your kid for hockey, a weekend warrior needing new discs for disc golf, or someone just looking to make a little cash from old equipment, this chain of secondhand sports stores might be the place for you. But how does it really work? Are the prices fair? Can you actually make money selling your used skates, bats, or dumbbells there? If you’ve ever wondered, you're not alone.

There’s a lot of chatter online about what it's like to bring gear to Play It Again Sports. Some say it's a breeze, while others feel like they didn’t get the best deal. I’ve seen people online talk about bringing in barely-used skates that cost over $100 and only getting $30 back. Others have worked at the store and say you can often negotiate if you hit the right vibe and bring your ID.

One thing’s for sure: it's not like selling on Kijiji or Facebook Marketplace. It’s faster, no doubt about it, but you might not get top dollar. Still, if you're looking for a hassle-free way to clear out old gear or find affordable equipment, Play It Again Sports could be worth a shot. Let’s break down what you should know before walking through those doors.

• Troian Bellisario Parents

Table of Contents

• What Is Play It Again Sports?
• How Does Play It Again Sports Work?
• Selling at Play It Again Sports: What to Expect
• Buying from Play It Again Sports: Smart Moves
• Play It Again Sports Locations: Not All Stores Are the Same
• Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Play It Again Sports?

Play It Again Sports is a franchise that specializes in secondhand sports equipment. With over 130 stores across the U.S. and Canada, it's become a popular option for people looking to save money on gear. Whether it's hockey skates, baseball bats, dumbbells, or even disc golf discs, you’ll often find a wide range of items in their stores.

It’s kind of like a GameStop, but for sports stuff. You bring in used gear, they look it over, and offer you a price. If you like what they’re offering, you walk out with cash or store credit. If not, you can just take your stuff and walk away. Pretty straightforward, right?

But here's the thing: each store is independently owned and operated, so the experience can vary depending on where you go. One store might be great for hockey gear, while another might be more into fitness or disc golf. That’s why it pays to do a little research before heading in with your stuff.

• Hdhub4u

How Does Play It Again Sports Work?

The process is pretty simple. You walk in with your gear, head to the counter, and let them know you want to sell. A staff member will take a look at what you've brought and give you a quote. They’ll check the condition, make sure it’s clean, and decide how much they’re willing to pay.

If you agree to the price, you’ll usually get paid in cash or store credit on the spot. Some people say you can negotiate a bit, especially if you have a bunch of items or if you're a regular. Just keep in mind that they’re a business, so they need to make a profit too.

One thing you should know: they might ask where you got the gear, and they may want to see your ID. This is to help prevent stolen goods from entering the system. So if you’ve got a pile of dumbbells or a bunch of used discs you're trying to offload, make sure you can prove they’re yours.

Selling at Play It Again Sports: What to Expect

If you're thinking of selling your used gear at Play It Again Sports, here are a few things to keep in mind:

• Condition matters: They want gear that’s still in good shape. Dirty or broken stuff might not be accepted.
• Prices aren’t always set in stone: Some people say you can haggle a bit, especially if you’ve got a lot of items or if you’re trading in store credit.
• Expect to get less than what you paid: It’s not a way to make a killing, but it’s a quick and easy way to make some extra cash without dealing with listings or shipping.
• Bring your ID: They might ask for it, especially if you’re trading in for cash.

One person online mentioned bringing in a pair of skates that were barely used but originally cost over $100. They ended up getting about $30 for them. Another person who works at a store in the Orlando area said they see a lot of hockey gear come through and that the prices are usually fair, especially if you’re a regular.

Buying from Play It Again Sports: Smart Moves

Buying used gear can be a great way to save money, especially if you're just getting into a sport or outfitting a kid who’s still growing out of gear every year.

One thing to look for is the condition. Just because something is on the shelf doesn’t mean it’s in perfect shape. Check for wear and tear, especially on items like skates or bats. You don’t want to buy something that’s going to fall apart after one use.

Also, don’t be afraid to ask questions. The staff often knows their stuff, and some have even worked in sports gear for years. If you're looking for something specific, like a 2018 DeMarini Juggy ASA bat or a 2019 Miken Freak Primo USSSA bat, it might be worth calling ahead to see if they have it in stock.

And if you’re into disc golf, you might want to stop by. One person who visited a Play It Again Sports store found a huge bin of used discs. A lot still had names and numbers on them, which can be a bit of a red flag if you're worried about resale value, but for someone just starting out, it could be a goldmine.

Play It Again Sports Locations: Not All Stores Are the Same

This is important: not all Play It Again Sports stores are created equal. Each one is independently owned, so the selection and pricing can vary a lot from one location to the next.

One person in the Seattle area said there are two stores nearby, but they each have different strengths. One is better for hockey gear, the other for fitness equipment. If you’re looking for something specific, it might be worth checking out a few stores or giving them a call before you go.

Also, if you’re in the market for selling or trading in your gear, it might help to find a store that deals in that type of equipment regularly. If you’ve got a bunch of dumbbells to sell, you’ll probably get a better offer at a store that sees a lot of fitness gear than one that mostly deals in hockey sticks.

And if you're lucky, your local high school team might even be sponsored by Play It Again Sports. One person mentioned that their team was sponsored by a local store, and they always got their gear there. That kind of connection can be a great way to build a relationship and get better deals over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are prices at Play It Again Sports negotiable?

Yes, in some cases. While the staff will usually give you an initial offer, some people say you can haggle a bit, especially if you’re trading in for store credit or if you have a lot of items. Just don’t expect to get full retail value—you’re not going to make a huge profit, but you can get a fair deal if you're willing to talk.

Can I sell used dumbbells at Play It Again Sports?

Some stores will accept dumbbells, but it depends on the location. One person online asked if anyone had sold dumbbells before and how much they got for them. Responses varied, but it seems like you might get between $10–$20 per dumbbell, depending on condition and brand. If you’ve got a full set, it could be worth trying, but don’t expect a huge payout.

Do they check where the gear came from?

Yes, they do. Because they’re a secondhand store, they want to make sure that the gear you’re selling isn’t stolen. They might ask how you got it, and they may want to see your ID before making a deal. So if you’re planning to sell, make sure you can prove the gear is yours.

What’s the best way to get a good deal when selling?

Clean your gear before bringing it in. Make sure everything is in good condition and free of dirt and grime. If you’re selling something like discs or skates, test them out to make sure they still work. Also, try to bring in a bunch of items together—it might help you get a better offer.

If you want to learn more about how to get the best deal when selling used gear, check out this external resource.

Learn more about selling used gear at Play It Again Sports and what to expect.